Easy Chewy Sugar Cookies Recipe – Soft, Simple, and Perfect for Christmas

Chewy Sugar Cookies Recipe: The Canvas of All Great Christmas Cookies

Every December, my kitchen turns into a sugar-dusted workshop of joy. Flour on the floor, cookie cutters clanging, and that unmistakable smell of vanilla in the air. And at the heart of it all? This chewy sugar cookies recipe. It’s not just a cookie—it’s the cookie. The one that disappears from the platter first, the one kids sneak before dinner, and the one I make in double batches because I know what’s coming.

When you’re building a holiday cookie box, texture matters. That’s why I love pairing these soft cookies with crisp options like my Cranberry Pistachio Shortbread Cookies. The contrast turns every bite into something more festive, more satisfying. And unlike crumbly sugar cookies that flake apart in your hands, these are chewy, rich, and hold up beautifully to frosting, packaging, and a good dunk in hot chocolate.

If you’re searching for a reliable base for your Christmas cookies, this recipe is it. No spreading, no hard edges—just buttery, golden cookies that stay soft for days and freeze like a dream. It’s a canvas for sprinkles, colored sugar, or even royal icing if you’re feeling ambitious.

Table of Contents of Easy Chewy Sugar Cookies Recipe

Table of Contents

The Canvas of Christmas Cookies

Let’s be honest—Christmas cookies are rarely just about flavor. They’re about color, shape, texture, and the variety you place in every tin. These chewy sugar cookies are what I call the “neutral anchor”—the soft vanilla balance in a box full of bold sweets.

Want jewel tones? Add Classic Raspberry Thumbprint Cookies. Craving something festive but oven-free while your sugar cookies cool? Make a tray of Crockpot Christmas Candy. They fill out the tin while the real star—your chewy sugar cookies—does its quiet, crowd-pleasing thing.

Every holiday season, I return to this recipe because it works. It bakes evenly, stores well, and plays nicely with others. These cookies are the unsung heroes of holiday baking—the quiet glue that ties the cookie box together.

Why Are They So Chewy? (Texture Science)

Butter, Sugar, and Technique

Let’s get into the science of the perfect chewy sugar cookies recipe—because that melt-in-your-mouth texture doesn’t happen by accident.

It starts with real butter. No shortening, no margarine. Softened unsalted butter creates a cookie that’s rich and tender without being greasy. When creamed with sugar, it traps air, giving the cookies a soft interior and just enough rise.

Next up: brown sugar. It’s the secret weapon. While many sugar cookie recipes use all white sugar, I prefer a split—about ¾ white and ¼ brown. The molasses in brown sugar adds moisture and chewiness, helping your cookies stay soft for days.

The eggs matter, too. One large egg adds structure, but don’t forget the extra yolk—that’s the trick for added richness and softness.

Want a great comparison? My Chewy Maple Pumpkin Cookies use nearly the same creaming method, but with autumnal spices. The chew is unmistakable.

Technique also plays a role. Don’t overmix once the flour goes in. Overworking the dough develops gluten, which leads to dense or tough cookies. Mix until just combined and let the dough rest before baking for best results.

Chilling the dough even for 30 minutes helps it hold its shape while baking, giving you thick, soft cookies that don’t spread thin or get crispy around the edges.

Salt, Vanilla, and Balance

You know what makes Christmas cookies stand out from the pack? Balance.

Too sweet, and they taste flat. Too plain, and they’re forgettable. That’s why every batch of my chewy sugar cookies includes a pinch of Pink Salt. Not table salt—just a touch of mineral-rich pink salt to enhance the vanilla flavor and cut the sweetness. It’s subtle, but it’s the kind of touch that separates good bakers from great ones.

And don’t skimp on the vanilla extract. Use real, not imitation. It’s the heart of the cookie, especially when you’re skipping bold spices or citrus zest.

With these tricks—creamed butter, brown sugar, egg yolk, pink salt, and real vanilla—you’re not just baking cookies. You’re baking memory makers.

Make Ahead, Freeze, and Store – Holiday Baking Strategy

Chill Time Is Flavor Time

There’s a reason bakers swear by chilling their dough, especially during the holidays. For this chewy sugar cookies recipe, a short chill makes a big difference.

Why? Because cold dough spreads less. It also gives the flour time to hydrate and the flavors to deepen, resulting in cookies with a rich vanilla profile and thick, soft centers. I typically chill mine for at least 30 minutes—longer if I’m cutting shapes or prepping for a party.

If you’re prepping your Christmas cookies over several days (because who has time to do it all at once?), this is where the strategy kicks in. You can mix the dough a day or two ahead, wrap it tightly in plastic, and chill it until you’re ready to bake.

Better yet? Scoop it into balls first. Place the dough balls on a sheet pan, freeze them until solid, and store them in a zip-top freezer bag for later. That way, you can bake a dozen cookies whenever you need them—fresh and warm, on demand.

Freezer Friendly and Frosting Ready

This chewy sugar cookies recipe is ideal for the freezer—not just the dough, but the finished cookies too. Once baked, allow them to cool completely, then layer between parchment in an airtight container. They’ll stay fresh in the freezer for up to 2 months.

When you’re ready to decorate, thaw the cookies at room temp and start frosting. They hold their shape perfectly and won’t crumble under pressure.

Decorating with kids? Make the cookies ahead, freeze them, then set up a frosting station on a quieter day. I like to do this the weekend before Christmas. While the kids frost, I set out a tray of Peppermint Oreo White Chocolate Bark for snacking—no ovens, no stress, just sweet holiday memories.

These cookies give you flexibility without compromise. Whether you’re baking for gifts, parties, or midnight snacks, they’re always ready when you are.

Cookie Box Pairings – Creating a Christmas Cookie Collection

Mix Texture and Color

One cookie never makes a Christmas tray. A holiday cookie box is a celebration of contrasts—soft and crunchy, pale and vibrant, rich and refreshing. That’s where this chewy sugar cookies recipe earns its place. Its subtle vanilla flavor and soft bite make it the anchor for any cookie spread.

But no box is complete without a little sparkle. I love pairing these sugar cookies with Classic Raspberry Thumbprint Cookies. Their ruby-red centers and buttery shortbread base create visual drama and fruity contrast next to the simplicity of a frosted sugar cookie.

Want something with crunch? Try Cranberry Pistachio Shortbread Cookies. Their crisp, nutty snap makes them the perfect foil to the chewy, pillowy texture of this sugar cookie.

These combinations aren’t just for flavor—they’re for gifting impact. When you open a cookie tin and see a mix of textures and colors, it feels more personal, more luxurious, more crafted. These chewy cookies give you that warm, nostalgic “classic” feel, while their companions add edge and elegance.

And don’t worry if you’re tight on time…

Oven Off? No Problem

Even the most dedicated holiday bakers eventually run out of oven space. That’s when it’s smart to fill out your cookie offerings with no-bake treats that contrast beautifully with baked goods.

While your sugar cookies cool (and your mixer takes a break), whip up a batch of Crockpot Christmas Candy. It’s a rich, chocolatey counterpoint to the clean vanilla profile of your sugar cookies—and it practically makes itself.

Another favorite of mine? Peppermint Oreo White Chocolate Bark. The cool peppermint crunch balances the warmth of baked goods, and it adds a festive pop of white and red to every holiday box.

This trio—chewy cookies, crisp shortbreads, and no-bake bark—delivers a holiday cookie box that looks professional but feels handmade.

When to Serve – Christmas Eve and Beyond

Pair with Cozy Drinks

There’s a reason chewy sugar cookies have a permanent spot on the Christmas Eve menu. They’re the cookies you leave for Santa, the ones dunked in milk or nibbled with a steaming mug of cocoa while watching snow fall through the window.

And when it comes to pairing, I always reach for my Peppermint Hot Chocolate. It’s sweet, creamy, and spiked with cool peppermint—exactly what these vanilla-forward cookies need for contrast. Plus, they’re firm enough to dunk but soft enough to soak up every sip.

Serving these at a holiday gathering? Stack them on a tray with mini mugs of hot chocolate for dipping, or pre-package them in clear bags tied with ribbon for guest take-home favors. This isn’t just dessert—it’s part of the Christmas experience.

Holiday Party Ready

While these cookies are stars on their own, I also love using them to balance out heavier dishes on a party table.

If you’re hosting a big holiday spread, start strong with a festive appetizer like my Pull-Apart Christmas Tree Garlic Bread. It’s savory, cheesy, and rich—which makes the lightness of sugar cookies the perfect closer.

They also work beautifully on dessert buffets alongside cakes and bars. When the end of the night hits and everyone wants just one more bite of something sweet (but not too rich), these cookies hit the mark.

Their shape and size make them easy to portion, easy to plate, and easy to love. Whether served with cocktails, cocoa, or coffee, their soft texture and frosted finish make them a seasonal must.

For the Guests Who Want Something Different

Fruity, Sticky, and Just as Festive

Let’s face it—while some guests can’t get enough classic sugar cookies, others are secretly wishing for something with a little more edge. That’s why I always make space for variety, especially when building a dessert tray or planning the Christmas Eve menu.

These chewy sugar cookies are soft and sweet, but what about something a bit stickier, nuttier, and bold? That’s where my Cranberry Pecan Pie Bars come in. They’ve got the same chewy texture but layered with jammy cranberry and crunchy pecans. One bite, and guests get that festive hit of sweet and tart that sugar cookies can’t deliver alone.

It’s not about replacing your sugar cookies. It’s about rounding out the offering so everyone finds something they love.

A Sweet Ending to a Savory Feast

Another great way to serve sugar cookies? As a light, simple finish after a rich Christmas dinner. Think roast beef, mashed potatoes, stuffing—and of course, my Mushroom Gravy Recipe.

After a meal like that, no one’s looking for a heavy dessert. That’s why these cookies work. They’re buttery but not overwhelming. Sweet but not cloying. You can eat just one and feel satisfied—or go back for three and not feel weighed down.

That’s what makes this chewy sugar cookies recipe so special. It plays well with others. It can be the main event, the quiet sidekick, or the backup treat when everything else has been devoured. In a season where everything is bold and busy, this cookie is soft, simple, and always welcome.

Frequently Asked Questions About Easy Chewy Sugar Cookies Recipe (FAQ)

Conclusion: The Cookie That Does It All

If there’s one recipe I return to again and again during the holidays, it’s this chewy sugar cookies recipe. It’s adaptable, giftable, and loved by all ages. You can dress it up or keep it classic, bake it ahead or whip it up the night before Christmas Eve. However you make them, these cookies always deliver—soft, buttery, and perfectly chewy.

Whether paired with peppermint cocoa or nestled beside shortbread in a festive cookie tin, they never disappoint. They’re the cookies that feel like home.

Did you try this menu? Tag me! I’d love to see your creations.
And if you want more holiday ideas and cookie inspiration…

👉 Follow me on Pinterest!

Print