Cherry Slab Pie Recipe: Simple, Crowd-Pleasing Dessert Everyone Loves

Cherry Slab Pie Recipe — Memories and Big-Batch Baking Joys

Cherry slab pie recipe has always been a family favorite in my kitchen. The first time I made it, I was barely tall enough to reach the counter, standing on a stool next to my grandmother as she rolled out the dough. That rustic aroma of buttery crust and bubbling cherries still brings back memories of summer picnics, county fairs, and cozy holidays where dessert always stole the spotlight.

There’s something magical about a slab pie — especially one packed with cherries. It’s bigger than a standard pie, easier to slice for a crowd, and just as flaky and delicious. Whenever I need a reliable dessert that wows guests and leaves no leftovers, I turn to this classic cherry slab pie recipe.

One of the best parts? It’s surprisingly flexible. Whether you’re baking from scratch or in a hurry, there’s a version that works. I’ve included my go-to full recipe below, but I’ll also show you how to whip up a 3-ingredient slab cherry pie when time’s tight. You’ll also get tips on making an easy cherry slab pie recipe using pantry staples, and even a sour cherry slab pie version for those who love that tart punch.

This dessert has seen birthdays, potlucks, and lazy Sundays in our home — and no matter the occasion, it never disappoints. With every golden, juicy slice, it reminds me why I fell in love with baking in the first place: simple ingredients, made with love, bringing people together.

Table of Contents

Table of Contents

Ingredients, Crust Tips & Cherry Variations

What You Need to Make the Perfect Cherry Slab Pie

Before you preheat the oven, gather everything you’ll need to make this cherry slab pie recipe stand out. The beauty of slab pies is their simplicity — one large baking sheet, a flaky crust, and a cherry filling that practically sings. Whether you’re going for a classic or the quick 3-ingredient slab cherry pie, start with quality ingredients.

Here’s a handy breakdown of essentials:

Ingredient	Purpose
Pie Crust (homemade or store-bought)	Base and top layer
Cherries (fresh, frozen, or canned)	Juicy, fruity center
Cornstarch	Thickens the filling
Sugar	Adds sweetness
Almond extract or vanilla	Flavor boost
Lemon juice	Brightens the cherry flavor

Fresh cherries are ideal in the summer, but don’t stress if you’re baking in winter. Frozen cherries work beautifully too — just thaw and drain them first. Canned cherries are an option, especially for the easy cherry slab pie recipe, but use ones packed in water or juice, not syrup.

For a bolder flavor, try making a sour cherry slab pie. Tart cherries balance beautifully with sugar and offer that old-fashioned zing your guests will rave about.

To amp up your cherry flavor without artificial taste, the pink salt trick recipe adds just a touch of contrast that makes cherries pop.

Print

Crust Choices & Pro Tips for a Flaky Finish

When it comes to the crust in any cherry slab pie recipe, you’ve got options. If you’re going all out, a homemade crust is unbeatable — golden, crisp, and rich with butter. But don’t worry, store-bought refrigerated dough is a time-saver that still tastes fantastic.

Here’s a quick overview:

Crust Type	Pros	Tips
Homemade Butter Crust	Rich flavor, flaky texture	Chill dough before rolling
Store-Bought Pie Dough	Fast, convenient	Bring to room temp before use
Puff Pastry	Light, crispy layers	Use for open-faced slab pies

For best results, always roll your dough slightly larger than your baking sheet. Gently press it into corners and up the sides. That helps hold all the cherry filling without overflow. If you’re topping your pie with a second crust, cut slits for ventilation — or go with a lattice pattern for a stunning finish.

Pro tip: brush the top crust with a beaten egg or milk and sprinkle with coarse sugar for that irresistible golden glow.

As you prep your crust and cherries, why not set the mood with a cold drink? This creamy strawberry apple punch recipe pairs beautifully with fruity desserts and makes baking even more fun.

And if you’re planning a dinner party around dessert, think savory first — like a Hawaiian huli huli chicken stack followed by cherry slab pie squares. It’s a pairing your guests won’t forget.

Step-by-Step Cherry Slab Pie Recipe Assembly and Baking

Assembling the Cherry Slab Pie Like a Pro

Now that your ingredients are prepped and your crust is ready, it’s time to assemble your cherry slab pie recipe with confidence. This part is surprisingly quick, and the results are always impressive. Start by preheating your oven to 375°F and lining your jelly roll pan or baking sheet with parchment paper for easy cleanup.

Roll out your bottom crust and gently press it into the pan. Make sure to leave a little overhang on the sides, which helps seal everything later. Spread the cherry filling evenly across the crust. If you’re using fresh cherries, make sure they’re pitted and halved. For frozen, thaw and drain well. Canned cherries? Drain and pat dry for best results.

Here’s a handy guide for baking sheet sizes and crust amounts:

Pan Size	Crust Needed	Cherry Filling (cups)
13×18″ sheet pan	Double batch (top + bottom)	5–6 cups
10×15″ jelly roll pan	1.5 batch	4 cups

Top your filling with the second crust. You can do a full sheet and cut steam vents, or get creative with lattice strips. Brush the top with egg wash and sprinkle coarse sugar for a golden finish. If you’re going with the 3-ingredient slab cherry pie shortcut using store-bought crust and cherry pie filling, you can still do this step and get great results with less prep.

Before baking, pop the assembled pie in the fridge for 15 minutes. This step helps the crust hold its shape and stay flaky. It’s a trick I learned after a few too many “melted edge” disasters.

Need a sweet treat to serve while it bakes? The caramel apple puppy chow is a fun snack that keeps the kids (and adults) happily distracted while the pie works its magic.

Baking and Cooling the Easy Cherry Slab Pie

Once the pie is chilled, bake it for 40–45 minutes, or until the top is golden and the filling is bubbling through the vents. If the edges start browning too quickly, tent them with foil during the last 10–15 minutes.

You’ll smell when it’s ready — that hypnotic mix of buttery pastry and syrupy cherries is unmistakable. But don’t rush to cut it just yet. For a cherry slab pie recipe to set up properly, it needs time to cool. Let it rest at room temperature for at least an hour. This allows the filling to thicken, so you get clean, neat squares when slicing.

Want a sour edge to your dessert? A sour cherry slab pie bakes the same way, but the filling might bubble a bit more aggressively due to the added juices. Just make sure to protect your oven with a lined baking sheet underneath.

If you’re serving this at a dinner party, plan a fun and satisfying main like the detox southwest chicken soup to keep the meal balanced. Follow it with chilled squares of cherry pie and you’ve got a feast to remember.

Finally, for those who love refreshing side salads with their fruity desserts, a spoonful of the Sbarro cucumber tomato salad adds a cool and tangy contrast to every rich bite.

Creative Ways to Serve and Store Your Cherry Slab Pie Recipe

Serving Suggestions for Cherry Slab Pie

Once your cherry slab pie recipe has cooled and the filling has set, it’s ready to be sliced and shared. One of the biggest perks of slab pies is how easily they serve a crowd. You can cut them into neat squares or generous rectangles, making them ideal for potlucks, school events, and weekend brunches.

For a classic presentation, serve the pie at room temperature with a scoop of vanilla ice cream or a dollop of whipped cream. Want to impress guests? Drizzle each slice with a light glaze made from powdered sugar and lemon juice — the citrus adds a tangy contrast to the cherries.

Here are three popular topping ideas that elevate this easy cherry slab pie:

Topping	Why It Works
Whipped Cream	Light and airy — balances rich cherry filling
Vanilla Ice Cream	Classic pairing that melts into the warm pie
Powdered Sugar Glaze	Adds shine and a sweet-tart flavor twist

For summer cookouts, pair the pie with grilled favorites like garlic parmesan cheeseburger bombs to create a bold sweet-and-savory spread.

This dessert also makes a strong showing at brunch tables. You can prep it the night before, chill it, and slice it cold — or bring it to room temp for a softer texture. Serve alongside fruit platters, breakfast casseroles, or a glass of bubbly for an indulgent treat.

Storage, Freezing & Reheating Tips

Made too much? Good news — your cherry slab pie recipe stores beautifully. Let leftovers cool completely, then transfer slices to an airtight container. Store in the fridge for up to four days.

For longer storage, freeze it. Wrap individual slices or full sections tightly in plastic wrap, then foil. Label and freeze for up to three months. When ready to serve, thaw in the fridge overnight and reheat in a 300°F oven for 10–15 minutes.

You can also serve it chilled — especially if you made a sour cherry slab pie, which tends to hold its structure better when cold. That tangy cherry flavor pops even more once it’s cooled down, giving you a firm bite and bold taste.

Planning a picnic or road trip? Pack cooled slices between layers of parchment in a sealed container. It’s way easier than transporting a round pie — no wobbling or spills.

As you prep your next batch or save slices for later, browse Epsilon’s homepage for meal ideas to pair with your pie. Whether it’s something hearty or light, you’ll find the perfect combo.

And if you’re craving a bright, easy snack for later in the week, check out these taco ranch bites in phyllo cups. They’re fun, fuss-free, and balance sweet desserts like cherry pie perfectly.

Finally, if you’ve followed the easy cherry slab pie recipe, storing and reheating is even simpler. Store-bought crusts and canned fillings are slightly sturdier, holding up well after refrigeration or freezing. So if you’re prepping in bulk for a party or bake sale, this shortcut works like a charm.

Cherry Slab Pie Recipe vs. Popular Variations: What’s the Difference?

Classic Cherry Slab Pie vs. 3-Ingredient Slab Cherry Pie

A classic cherry slab pie recipe involves layering homemade or store-bought crust with a juicy cherry filling made from scratch. It’s flavorful, rustic, and ideal when you’ve got a bit of time to bake with care. It lets you adjust sweetness, texture, and cherry intensity to your liking. Plus, you can mix in spices like cinnamon or a splash of almond extract to personalize it.

On the other hand, a 3-ingredient slab cherry pie is perfect for busy bakers or those just starting out. All you need is pre-made pie crust, canned cherry pie filling, and an egg for brushing the top. It’s fast, fuss-free, and still totally delicious. You lose a bit of control over flavor and texture, but it’s a lifesaver when you need a dessert in under an hour.

Here’s a side-by-side comparison:

Feature	Classic Cherry Slab Pie	3-Ingredient Slab Cherry Pie
Prep Time	60–75 minutes	20–25 minutes
Flavor Control	High — fully customizable	Low — canned filling taste
Crust Type	Homemade or store-bought	Pre-made crust only
Best For	Family gatherings, holidays	Quick desserts, kids’ parties

Whether you go full homemade or lean on shortcuts, both styles deliver on taste and satisfaction.

Internal pairing idea? Try the fast pie with something bright and citrusy like this pineapple bake recipe Longhorn-style for a sweet-and-tart flavor duo.

Sour Cherry Slab Pie vs. Easy Cherry Slab Pie Recipe

The biggest difference between a sour cherry slab pie and an easy cherry slab pie recipe lies in the flavor profile and ingredient choice. Sour cherries (also known as tart cherries or Montmorency) have a vibrant, tangy bite that’s less sugary. They’re perfect if you enjoy a punchier, less sweet dessert.

To make it, you’ll likely need a bit more sugar and a touch of cornstarch to balance the acidity. Sour cherry slab pie is often described as “old-school,” since many classic bakeries used sour cherries before sweet varieties became common.

In contrast, an easy cherry slab pie recipe typically uses canned cherry pie filling (usually sweetened Bing cherries) and pre-rolled crusts. It’s soft, sweet, and always crowd-friendly — especially with ice cream.

Here’s when to go with each:

• Pick sour cherry slab pie when you want a bold, grown-up flavor.
• Choose easy cherry slab pie for a universally loved, mellow dessert.

You can even serve both at events to offer variety — just label them so guests can pick their favorite!

And for a bonus tip: balance sour pie with a smooth drink like this creamy strawberry apple punch, or serve sweet pie after a light meal like Sbarro’s cucumber tomato salad.

Frequently Asked Questions About Cherry Slab Pie Recipe

Conclusion

The cherry slab pie recipe isn’t just another dessert — it’s a celebration on a sheet pan. From the buttery crust to the rich cherry filling, every bite delivers comfort, color, and just the right touch of nostalgia. Whether you go with the full recipe, the easy cherry slab pie, or a fast 3-ingredient slab cherry pie, you’re guaranteed smiles all around.

Perfect for parties, potlucks, or weekend baking therapy, this recipe adapts to any season and skill level. With just a little effort and love, you’ll create a dessert that’s timeless, tasty, and totally shareable.

Want more inspiration? Check out the full collection of slab pie ideas at AllRecipes Slab Pie Collection.