Costco Lobster Mac and Cheese Recipe (How to Make It Copycat Style)

Costco Lobster Mac and Cheese: Creamy, Cheesy, and Loaded with Lobster

Introduction

If you’re anything like me, you’ve probably paused in front of Costco’s deli section, spotted that golden tray of Costco Lobster Mac and Cheese, and thought: “Can this really be as good as it looks?” Spoiler alert—it is. Rich, buttery lobster in a sea of bubbling cheddar cream sauce—it’s pure indulgence. But what if I told you this flavor bomb is easy (and way more generous with lobster) when made at home? This guide walks you through the ultimate Copycat Costco Lobster Mac and Cheese recipe—from cooking tips for the store-bought version to recreating it from scratch. Bonus? I’ve got amazing seafood sides like this Honey Garlic Shrimp Recipe to pair with it.

Table of Contents

Table of Contents

My Costco Lobster Mac and Cheese Discovery

My First Bite of Costco Lobster Mac and Cheese (Copycat Recipe Roots)

The first time I tasted Costco Lobster Mac and Cheese, I wasn’t expecting fireworks. It was one of those days—rushed, hungry, and looking for a dinner shortcut. I tossed the tray into the cart, not really thinking twice. But that night, as it baked to bubbly perfection and filled my kitchen with the smell of garlic butter and cheddar, I realized this wasn’t your average frozen meal.

When I took that first bite, the balance hit me instantly—sweet lobster claw meat, perfectly al dente pasta, and a luscious three-cheese blend. It was rich, yes, but not overwhelming. That moment sparked something in me as a chef. I thought, “What if I could make this at home—but better?”

So I did. I tested different cheese combinations, swapped in cavatappi for a gourmet touch, and made sure every forkful was packed with real lobster meat. This wasn’t just another cheesy casserole. It became my go-to for holidays, cold nights, or whenever I wanted to impress without stress.

This Copycat Costco Lobster Mac and Cheese recipe is the result—decadent, creamy, and totally doable at home. The kind of dish that makes you feel like a kitchen boss, even on a Tuesday.

You’ll find it lands somewhere between a classic mac and cheese and a creamy seafood bake—like my Chicken Broccoli Alfredo Bake, only seafood-centric. And trust me, it’s way more generous with lobster than anything you’ll buy premade.

Why Make It at Home? (Cost, Quality, and Satisfaction)

Let’s be real. The Costco version is convenient—but it’s not cheap. A single tray often costs upwards of $20 and barely feeds two hungry people. When you break down the cost, you’re paying a premium for minimal lobster and a basic sauce. But when you make it at home? You control everything. And I mean everything.

Want more lobster? Add it. Prefer a sharper cheddar? Go for it. Like a golden breadcrumb crust with a Parmesan kick? I’ve got you. Homemade means fresher ingredients, bigger portions, and better balance. You’ll spend less per serving, especially if you buy lobster tails in bulk or use leftover steamed lobster.

And let’s not forget quality. You’re not limited to the ingredients in the Costco tray. I prefer using freshly grated cheese (melts like a dream), real heavy cream, and seasoning that gives it depth—think smoked paprika, garlic, and even a touch of Dijon for zip.

This is comfort food at its best—elevated without feeling fussy. It’s as satisfying as my Crockpot Lasagna Soup with Marinara Sauce—rich, cheesy, and spoon-worthy. But it also makes a statement. Serve it in ramekins for date night, or bake it in a big dish for the holidays. Either way, it’s a total showstopper.

And yes, leftovers reheat like a dream.

Bought the Kit? How to Cook (and Improve) Costco Lobster Mac and Cheese

Step-by-Step: How to Cook Costco Lobster Mac and Cheese Perfectly

So you picked up the premade tray of Costco Lobster Mac and Cheese and you’re ready to serve a satisfying, seafood-packed meal. First—smart choice. It’s one of Costco’s best deli picks when you want something luxurious without spending hours in the kitchen. But even pre-made meals benefit from a little chef-level finesse.

Here’s how to cook Costco’s version to creamy, bubbling perfection.

Cooking Instructions for Costco Lobster Mac and Cheese (Oven Method):

1. Preheat oven to 400°F.
2. Remove the plastic lid and cover the tray tightly with foil to keep moisture in.
3. Place on a baking sheet for stability.
4. Bake covered for 35–40 minutes.
5. Remove the foil and broil on high for 2–3 minutes until the cheese topping browns slightly.

Internal temp should hit 165°F, so double-check with a thermometer. You’ll notice the cheese gets golden, and the lobster begins to infuse the entire tray with flavor.

While this cooking method works well, there are a few easy upgrades that can take it from “store-bought” to “wow, who made this?” Let’s move on to that.

Adriana’s Chef Tip: How to Doctor It Up Like a Pro

Even the best store-bought dishes can use a little love—and the Costco Lobster Mac and Cheese is no different. If you’re serving guests or just want to treat yourself, here are my go-to “doctor it up” tips:

1. Add more lobster.
The tray doesn’t always deliver on meat-to-pasta ratio. Add chunks of cooked lobster tail or claw meat before baking. You’ll instantly transform it into a premium dish that rivals restaurant quality.

2. Splash in some cream.
Before baking, stir in 2 tablespoons of heavy cream or crème fraîche. It enriches the sauce and gives you that ultra-silky texture the premade version sometimes lacks.

3. Layer on extra cheese.
Mix some shredded gruyere, mozzarella, or parmesan into the top layer before baking. I often add white cheddar for a sharper bite and creamier melt.

4. Add seasoning.
The tray can be a bit mild. Sprinkle in a bit of garlic powder, smoked paprika, or a dash of cayenne for more depth. Want bold? A pinch of Old Bay or seafood seasoning brings it home.

5. Breadcrumb topping = golden crust.
Melt 2 tablespoons butter, mix with ½ cup panko breadcrumbs and ¼ cup grated parmesan. Sprinkle on top before baking uncovered for the final 10 minutes.

Now you’ve gone from boxed heat-and-eat to gourmet-level mac and cheese. Pair it with something comforting like these Garlic Parmesan Cheeseburger Bombs or serve as the star of a seafood feast next to my Mushroom Stuffed Chicken Breast.

Chef Adriana’s Tip:
Make the tray stretch! Add 1 cup cooked cavatappi and an extra ½ cup sauce (butter + cheese or cream) to bulk up servings while keeping flavor intact.

Homemade Copycat Costco Lobster Mac and Cheese Recipe

Ingredients and Flavor Notes (Creamy, Cheesy, Seafood-Rich)

When I decided to recreate Costco Lobster Mac and Cheese from scratch, I knew I had to go bigger. More lobster, a dreamier sauce, and a pasta shape that holds onto all that velvety cheese. The result? This Copycat Costco Lobster Mac and Cheese recipe is loaded with lobster and layered with deep, satisfying flavor in every bite.

Here’s what you’ll need and why each one matters:

• Pasta (1 lb cavatappi or elbow macaroni): I love cavatappi because it grabs the sauce like a sponge. You can use elbows for a more classic touch.
• Lobster meat (12 oz cooked, chopped): Go with claw or tail meat for best texture. Use fresh steamed lobster or high-quality frozen.
• Butter (6 tbsp): The base of a rich roux.
• All-purpose flour (¼ cup): Thickens the cheese sauce without making it too heavy.
• Whole milk (2½ cups) + Heavy cream (1 cup): A luxurious combo that gives the sauce its signature creaminess.
• Cheeses:
• Sharp white cheddar (2 cups shredded)
• Fontina (1 cup shredded)
• Gruyère (½ cup shredded)
• Parmesan (¼ cup, for topping)
• Dijon mustard (1 tsp): Adds brightness and sharpens the flavor.
• Sea salt, garlic powder, smoked paprika, black pepper: Key seasonings.
• Optional breadcrumb topping: Mix ½ cup panko with 2 tbsp melted butter and ¼ cup Parmesan for a crisp finish.

This combo results in a sauce that’s smooth, sharp, and never greasy. It’s close to what you’d expect from a restaurant lobster mac, not just a quick-fix side. The seafood doesn’t get lost—it’s the hero.

And if you love cozy pasta dinners, this dish sits right alongside favorites like my Turkey Tenderloin with Herb Butter or Mongolian Ground Beef Noodles for a weeknight win.

Full Recipe with Chef Tips for Best Texture

Instructions:

1. Preheat oven to 375°F. Grease a 9×13” baking dish or 6 individual ramekins.
2. Boil pasta until al dente. Drain and toss with a splash of olive oil to prevent sticking.
3. Make the roux: In a large saucepan, melt butter over medium heat. Whisk in flour and cook 2–3 minutes until lightly golden.
4. Build the sauce: Gradually whisk in milk and cream. Bring to a gentle simmer and stir until smooth.
5. Season: Stir in Dijon mustard, garlic powder, smoked paprika, salt, and pepper.
6. Add cheese: Lower heat and add shredded cheddar, fontina, and gruyère. Stir until fully melted.
7. Combine everything: Add drained pasta and lobster to the sauce. Gently fold together.
8. Transfer to baking dish. Top with extra cheese or buttered breadcrumbs.
9. Bake uncovered for 20–25 minutes, or until bubbling. Broil for 2 minutes to brown the top.
10. Cool slightly before serving. The sauce thickens as it rests.

Chef Adriana’s Serving Note: This mac is rich—serve smaller portions and balance it with a fresh side like coleslaw or a crisp green salad. Or go indulgent and add my Butternut Squash and Sausage Tortellini Soup for a decadent winter feast.

Storage Tips:
Store leftovers in an airtight container up to 3 days. Reheat in the oven at 325°F with a splash of milk or cream stirred in. Avoid microwaving—it ruins the texture.

Freezing Tip:
Freeze pre-baked for up to 2 months. Thaw overnight and bake at 350°F for 30–40 minutes.

What to Serve: Best Sides for Lobster Mac and Cheese

Fresh and Tangy Sides to Balance the Richness

Let’s be honest: Costco Lobster Mac and Cheese is rich, creamy, and indulgent—basically the food equivalent of a warm blanket. But with a dish this decadent, the right side dishes can make the meal sing. I always recommend something bright and fresh to cut through the creaminess.

One of my go-to sides? A crisp coleslaw with a tropical twist. Think Hawaiian-style slaw with shredded cabbage, pineapple, lime juice, and just a touch of mayo. It adds crunch and tang that perfectly balances the deep, buttery lobster flavor.

Another fresh winner? Roasted Brussels sprouts. Charred and seasoned with a little balsamic glaze, they’re earthy, slightly sweet, and just bitter enough to create contrast. And they go especially well if you’re serving the mac and cheese with a glass of white wine or sparkling cider.

If you’re planning a dinner party or just want to round out your plate, try pairing it with the Longhorn Steakhouse Pineapple Bake—that sweet-savory combo is magic next to creamy pasta. You can grab the recipe right here.

Looking for a protein side? My Mushroom Stuffed Chicken Breast adds elegance to the plate without stealing the spotlight.

Here’s a quick table to help you mix and match:

Type of Side	Recommended Dish
Crisp & Tangy	Hawaiian Coleslaw
Vegetable	Roasted Brussels Sprouts
Savory-Sweet	Pineapple Bake
Protein	Stuffed Chicken Breast

These sides not only round out the plate—they make the entire meal feel intentional and memorable.

Complete Dinner Ideas with Comfort Food Favorites

If you’re like me, once you start building a comfort food menu, it’s hard to stop. For those times when you want a meal that feels like a big warm hug, Costco Lobster Mac and Cheese makes the perfect centerpiece—and these dishes build a full menu around it.

Start with something fun and shareable. My Easy Mozzarella Stuffed Meatballs are bite-sized, cheesy, and full of flavor. They pair surprisingly well with lobster mac, especially if you’re feeding a crowd.

Or bring in smoky flavors with my Smoked Chuck Roast—a bold, beefy partner that contrasts beautifully with the seafood richness.

Feeling cozy? A small bowl of Butternut Squash and Sausage Tortellini Soup served on the side warms the soul and plays off the sweet lobster and sharp cheddar.

Weekend dinner idea:

• Starter: Hawaiian Slaw
• Main: Copycat Costco Lobster Mac and Cheese
• Side: Pineapple Bake
• Dessert: Apple crisp or key lime pie

Chef Adriana’s Hosting Tip: Serve lobster mac in individual ramekins on a large dinner plate. Add one savory side and one green or tangy one. This adds color, variety, and keeps portions satisfying.

Chef Adriana’s FAQ Kitchen – Your Lobster Mac Questions Answered

Real Costco Questions And Food Origins & Trivia Corner

The Costco Lobster Mac and Cheese is very much an American comfort food—with a gourmet twist.

Conclusion: Why This Copycat Costco Lobster Mac and Cheese is Worth Making

Whether you’re cooking straight from the tray or making your own from scratch, Costco Lobster Mac and Cheese proves that comfort food can feel fancy. But the truth is—when you make it yourself, you get the best of all worlds: more flavor, more lobster, and a lot more satisfaction.

This Copycat Costco Lobster Mac and Cheese recipe gives you that creamy, cheesy bite you love—with chef-worthy upgrades that turn an everyday dinner into something special. It’s perfect for holidays, cold nights, or when you want to wow your guests without breaking a sweat.

And let’s not forget—this dish pairs beautifully with everything from Pineapple Bake to Smoked Chuck Roast, making it a versatile main course you’ll come back to again and again.

If you want to see what others are saying, check out this full Costco Mac and Cheese review for tips and flavor breakdowns.

Print